Excerpts from Annotated Bibliographies

Bergmann, S. (1989). Discipline and guidance: A thin line in the middle school. What at-risk student say about middle level school discipline and teaching. Reston, VA: National Association of Secondary School Principals. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 309 333)

This study was intended to assess student perceptions of school discipline effectiveness, teaching strategies, and school climate. Two hundred and twenty (220) middle school students (ages 11 through 16) in twenty middle schools responded to the survey and represented large, urban, suburban, and rural settings. Results showed a more positive student perception of their schools than was expected. Also, over 50% responded favorably regarding all three areas of the study. In one area, school climate, students indicated the desire to have more time for socializing with their peers and for greater opportunity to have school personnel listen to student problems.


Adams, J. J., & Baker, L. T. (1993). The preparation of rural school administrators. The Rural Educationist, 13 (2), 5-9.

The survey of superintendents and principals in North Dakota, South Dakota, and Nebraska suggests that many administrative preparation programs place too much emphasis on the problems of urban areas, ignoring many of the special problems of rural districts. Although the authors acknowledge that textbooks are unlikely to be changed, they suggest that institutions preparing rural administrators move to a problem-based approach with emphasis on case studies involving rural areas.


Anderson, V. H. (1990). The overage student: Candidate for school failure. Oregon: Portland State University.

Anderson examines the effects of students that are overage for their appropriate grade level. She discusses overage as being an indicator of increased school failure as well as being a factor in drop-out rates. (p. 4-13)

"This study adds validation to the literature which overwhelmingly fails to support retention or other interventions which leave students overage for grade." (p. 4-5)

"One such variable is in-grade retention, a common educational strategy for dealing with students at-risk." (p. 11)

"In-grade retentions account for the vast majority of students above the modal age for grade." (p. 14)

"A reaffirmation of rigorous academic standards and the establishment of promotional gates as academic safeguards have failed to benefit the academically and socially at-risk students." (p. 39)

"Retention is also frequently cited as a variable associated with student failure." (p. 40)

"Many researchers have stated the practice flourishes in the absence of any other interventions which may be appropriate responses when students fail to achieve." (p. 48)


Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Macmillan.

Dewey generalizes on many types of experiences with an emphasis on the rural schools. "Sound educational experiences involves, above all, continuity and interaction between the learner and what is learned." (p. 5)

"Everything depends upon the quality of the experience which is had. The central problem of an education based upon experience is to select the kind of present experiences that live fruitfully and creatively in subsequent experiences." (p. 17)


Barth, R. S. (1997). Forward. In M. Fullan, What's worth fighting for in the principalship. NY: Teachers College Press, Columbia University.

"Schools and school systems are unsuccessful at many things. One area in which they excel is in promoting a culture of dependency. 'What am I suppose to do?' the superintendent must ask of the local and state boards. Then memos go out to principals who respond, 'What am I suppose to do?' Principals, in turn, put memos in teachers' boxes--or in their e-mail. Teachers respond, 'What am I suppose to do?' Teachers in turn put assignments on pupils' desks which are greeted by students with, 'What am I suppose to do?' And so it goes. This is a pathological pattern, Michael Fullan persuasively argues, worth fighting against." (pp. vii-viii)